Terminology » Networking Basics » Frame Relay: Advantages and Disadvantages Explained

Frame Relay: Advantages and Disadvantages Explained

frame relay data communication wan networking basics packet switching

This page explores the advantages and disadvantages of Frame Relay technology. It covers the benefits and drawbacks of Frame Relay, along with a basic introduction to the technology itself.

What is Frame Relay?

Frame Relay is a data transmission technology designed for high-speed communication, similar to ISDN. It’s a packet-switching technology that operates at layers 1 and 2 of the OSI model.

Frame Relay establishes connections between Data Terminal Equipment (DTE) and Data Circuit-terminating Equipment (DCE) using two modes:

  • PVC (Permanent Virtual Circuit): A static connection, similar to leased lines.
  • SVC (Switched Virtual Circuit): A dynamically established connection.

Frame Relay network Figure 1: Frame Relay Network

The figure above illustrates a Frame Relay network, consisting of Frame Relay switches connecting DTEs and DCEs. Each connection is identified by a unique DLCI (Data Link Connection Identifier) within the Frame Relay frame.

Benefits or Advantages of Frame Relay

Here are the primary benefits of using Frame Relay:

  • Higher Speeds: Frame Relay offers higher speeds due to the lack of error detection at the Frame Relay layer, resulting in less overhead and higher throughput compared to X.25.
  • Dynamic Bandwidth Allocation: Bandwidth can be allocated dynamically based on current needs.
  • Reduced Network Overhead: The incorporation of congestion control mechanisms minimizes network overhead.
  • Support for Bursty Data: It efficiently handles bursty data traffic that doesn’t have a fixed data rate.
  • Layer 1 and 2 Operation: Frame Relay operates at the physical (Layer 1) and data link (Layer 2) layers, making it easy to integrate with devices that have Layer 3 (network) functionalities.
  • Large Frame Size: It allows for frame sizes of up to 9000 bytes, which is sufficient for most LAN frame types.
  • Cost-Effective: Frame Relay is generally less expensive than traditional WAN networks.
  • Guaranteed Throughput and Delay: Frame Relay can offer guarantees regarding throughput and delay.
  • Secured Connection: Provides a secure connection because it is difficult to break into PVCs between sites.

Drawbacks or Disadvantages of Frame Relay

Here are the main disadvantages of Frame Relay:

  • Lack of Flow and Error Control: Frame Relay itself doesn’t provide flow control or error control mechanisms. These functions need to be handled by upper-layer protocols.
  • Packet Delay: Packets can experience additional delay as they pass through each network node.
  • Data and Processing Overhead: Each packet incurs data and processing overhead.
  • Variable Length Frames: The use of variable-length frames can lead to varying delays for different users.
  • Unsuitable for Real-Time Data: Due to varying delays, it’s not well-suited for sending sensitive real-time data, such as voice or video.
  • Limited Data Rate: With a maximum operating speed of 44.376 Mbps, it’s not suitable for protocols requiring higher data rates.
  • More Expensive than Internet: Typically more expensive than a standard internet service.