Terminology » Zigbee » Zigbee vs. IR Remote Control: A Detailed Comparison

Zigbee vs. IR Remote Control: A Detailed Comparison

zigbee ir remote remote control wireless technology home automation

This article provides a comparison between Zigbee and IR (Infrared) remote controls, highlighting their key differences in terms of specifications, operational principles, and applications.

Specifications: IR Remote Control vs. Zigbee Remote Control

The following table summarizes the key specifications and differences between the two technologies:

FeatureIR Remote ControlZigbee Remote Control
Frequency RangeInfrared wavelength/frequency: 700 nm to 1 mm wavelength, 430 THz to 300 GHz frequency.2.4 GHz or 868/915 MHz.
PrincipleOperates based on IR codes defined by manufacturers. Interoperability between devices from different manufacturers is limited.Zigbee Profile defines commands and responses, enabling interoperability between devices from different manufacturers.
Coverage RangeUp to 10 meters.Up to 50 meters.
Data Rate500 bps to 1 kbps.250 Kbps (2.4 GHz), 20 kbps (868 MHz), 40 kbps (915 MHz).
Regional RegulationNo specific limitations.Subject to regulation limits defined in ETSI/FCC. Compliance tests are required.
BidirectionalNot possible due to power consumption constraints.Possible.
Operational RangeRequires Line of Sight (LOS) between devices.Does not require LOS. Devices can communicate even without a direct visual path.
Frame SizeMaximum 40 bits per frame.Zigbee frames can carry a maximum payload of 127 bytes.
Modulation/CodingUses modulation techniques like pulse distance coding and Manchester coding on a 38 KHz carrier.Zigbee employs O-QPSK modulation in the 2.4 GHz band and BPSK modulation in the 868 MHz/915 MHz bands.
ApplicationsPrimarily used for TV, VCR, and other simple remote controls.Extends beyond remote control to include home automation, lighting systems, parking systems, wireless sensor networks, and various IoT applications.

Key Differences Explained

Let’s delve deeper into the differences outlined in the table:

  • Interoperability: IR remote controls rely on manufacturer-specific codes, making it difficult to use a single remote for devices from different brands. Zigbee, on the other hand, promotes interoperability through its standardized profiles.

  • Range and Obstacles: IR remotes have a limited range and require a direct line of sight. Zigbee offers a greater range and can penetrate obstacles, providing more flexibility in device placement.

  • Data Rate and Bidirectional Communication: Zigbee’s higher data rate and support for bidirectional communication enable more complex functionalities and feedback mechanisms, unlike the unidirectional nature of IR remotes.

  • Applications: While IR remotes are largely confined to basic control functions, Zigbee’s capabilities make it suitable for a wide range of applications, particularly in the realm of IoT and smart home automation.