Carbon Resistor vs. Wire Wound Resistor: Key Differences

resistor
carbon
wire wound
component
electronic

This page highlights the fundamental differences between carbon resistors and wire wound resistors. As we know, a resistor is a device that impedes the flow of electric current. Its resistance is measured in Ohms. Here’s a breakdown of these two common types:

Carbon Resistor

A carbon resistor is made primarily of carbon or graphite.

Advantages of Carbon Resistors

  • Small Size & Lightweight: They are physically compact and don’t add much weight to a circuit.
  • Suitable for High-Frequency Circuits: Carbon composition allows them to operate effectively in high-frequency applications.
  • Low Temperature Coefficient: Their resistance changes relatively little with temperature fluctuations.
  • Easy to Manufacture High Values: Creating high-value resistors is simpler with carbon composition.

Disadvantages of Carbon Resistors

  • Susceptible to Environmental Changes: Their resistance can be affected by changes in temperature and humidity.
  • Limited Power Handling: The current carrying capacity, and therefore the power (wattage) they can handle, is limited to around 2 Watts.
  • Difficult to Manufacture Low Values: Making carbon resistors with values less than approximately 2 Ohms is challenging.
  • Poor Stability & Reliability: Compared to other types, carbon resistors aren’t as stable or reliable over time.

Carbon resistors come in two primary forms: composition type and film type.

carbon resistor vs wire wound resistor

Wire Wound Resistor

A wire wound resistor is constructed by winding a wire (typically a high-resistance alloy) around an insulated core.

Advantages of Wire Wound Resistors

  • High Stability & Reliability: They offer excellent stability and consistent performance over long periods.
  • High Power Rating & Low Tolerance: They can handle significant power and are manufactured with precise resistance values (low tolerance).
  • Easy to Manufacture Low Values: Creating wire wound resistors with values as low as 0.01 Ohm is readily achievable.

Disadvantages of Wire Wound Resistors

  • Difficult to Manufacture High Values: Making wire wound resistors with values in the Mega Ohm range is difficult.
  • Difficult to Create Variable Types: Constructing variable wire wound resistors is more complex than with other types.
  • Not Suitable for High-Frequency Circuits: Their inductive properties make them less suitable for high-frequency applications.
  • Large Size: They tend to be physically larger than carbon resistors, which can be a limitation in some applications.

The wire wound resistor is also commonly known as a rheostat when used as a variable resistor.

Power Resistor Fundamentals

Explore the features of power resistors, designed for high-power applications, including their construction, capabilities, and common manufacturers.

power resistor
resistor
component
LDR (Light Dependent Resistor) Basics

LDR (Light Dependent Resistor) Basics

Learn the fundamentals of LDRs (Light Dependent Resistors), their characteristics, types, and applications. Also find a list of LDR manufacturers.

ldr
resistor
photoresistor