RFIPsec vs L2TP vs PPTP: Protocol Comparison
Advertisement
This article compares IPsec, L2TP, and PPTP, highlighting their similarities and differences. The following table summarizes the key aspects of IPsec, L2TP, and PPTP protocols.
IPsec vs L2TP vs PPTP Comparison Table
| Feature | IPsec | PPTP | L2TP |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full form | IP Security | Point to Point Tunneling Protocol | Layer2 Tunneling Protocol |
| OSI Layer | Layer-3 (Network Layer) | Layer-2 (Data Link Layer) | Layer-2 (Data Link Layer) |
| Transport Protocols | IP (Internet Protocol) | IP, NetBEUI, IPX | IP, NetBEUI, IPX |
| Underlying Protocol Needed | IP | IP | IP, Frame Relay, X.25, ATM |
| No. of Tunnels Supported | 1 | 1 | Several |
| User Authentication | NO | YES (PAP, EAP, CHAP, SPAP) | YES (Same As Above) |
| Packet Authentication | YES (HMAC SHA-1, HMAC MD5) | NO | NO |
| Packet Encryption | YES (DES, 3DES) | NO | NO |
| Key Management | YES (IKE) | NO | NO |
| Vulnerability to Attacks | Resistant | Not resistant | Not resistant |
| Appropriate Use | Securing intranet (unicast only). | Remote access VPN, Branch office VPN, Extranet VPN | Remote access VPN, Branch office VPN, Extranet VPN |
| More Information |
Key Takeaways
- IPsec: Prioritizes security with strong encryption and authentication. Operates at the network layer.
- PPTP: An older protocol. While easy to configure, it lacks inherent security features like encryption and is vulnerable to attacks. Operates at the data link layer.
- L2TP: Operates at the data link layer. It doesn’t provide encryption on its own and is often used in conjunction with IPsec for enhanced security.
Advertisement
