RFNXDN vs DMR: Digital Radio Protocol Comparison
Advertisement
NXDN and DMR are both digital radio communication solutions designed for professional and commercial use, offering enhancements over traditional analog systems. They provide improved voice quality, data capabilities, enhanced security, and better spectrum efficiency.
While sharing similarities, NXDN and DMR differ in modulation schemes, access techniques, bandwidths, and the standards organizations that define them. Both are open standards, ensuring interoperability between equipment from various manufacturers.
Both NXDN and DMR primarily operate in the VHF (136-174 MHz) and UHF (403-470 MHz) bands, subject to regional regulations and licensing.
What is NXDN?
NXDN, short for Narrowband Digital Exchange, is defined by Icom Incorporated and Kenwood Corporation. It utilizes FDMA (Frequency Division Multiple Access) technology in the VHF/UHF bands. Key specifications include:
- Clear Voice Quality: Minimal background noise and interference.
- Secure Communication: Digital encryption capabilities.
- Channel Bandwidth: Operates on either a 12.5 kHz or 6.25 kHz channel, using a single carrier per channel.
- Multi-Site Trunking: Seamless communication across a wide area by interconnecting multiple base stations.
- Data Applications: Supports text messaging, telemetry, status monitoring, and GPS location tracking.
- Extended Coverage: Better coverage and range compared to analog systems.
- Roaming Capabilities: Supported in some systems.
- Analog/Digital Compatibility: Many radios support both modes for a smooth transition.
What is DMR?
DMR, or Digital Mobile Radio, is developed by the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI) and supported by the DMR Association. It’s designed for professional and commercial two-way radio applications.
It operates in VHF and UHF bands and uses TDMA (Time Division Multiple Access) to allow two voice channels to share the same radio frequency, effectively doubling the number of users and increasing spectrum efficiency.
Key specifications of DMR include:
- Clear Voice Quality: Consistent voice quality.
- TDMA Technology: Uses two time slots in a 12.5 kHz channel, enabling two simultaneous voice or data calls (as shown in the figure above).
- Data Applications: Supports text messaging, telemetry, GPS location tracking, status messaging, etc.
- Secure Transmission: Built-in encryption for secure voice and data transmission.
- Improved Coverage: Better signal propagation for enhanced coverage and range compared to analog systems.
- Extended Battery Life: TDMA technology results in lower power consumption.
- Call Management: Supports group calls, individual calls, and broadcast messages.
- Roaming Support: Seamless handovers between different coverage regions.
For a deeper understanding, refer to DMR tutorials covering system basics, features, network architecture, air interface, channel types, and benefits.
Difference between NXDN and DMR Technologies
Let’s compare NXDN and DMR based on their benefits and features.
| Specifications | NXDN | DMR |
|---|---|---|
| Full Form | Next Generation Digital Narrowband | Digital Mobile Radio |
| Access Technique | FDMA (Frequency Division Multiple Access) | TDMA (Time Division Multiple Access) |
| Resource Allocation | Uses a single carrier on a channel at a time. | Allows two carriers on a channel, separated in time. Uses 2 time slots over a 12.5 kHz channel for two communication paths. |
| Channel Bandwidth | Operates on 12.5 kHz or 6.25 kHz channel bandwidth. | Supports operation on a 12.5 kHz channel only. |
| Modes | Conventional Mode (NXDN Type-C), Trunked Mode (NXDN Type-Trunking), Multi-Site Trunking (NXDN Type-D), Direct Mode (NXDN Type-Digital Trunking Direct Mode Operation) | Categorized into three tiers: Tier-I, Tier-II, and Tier-III (Refer to DMR Tier-1 to 3). |
| Codec rate | 3600 bps and 7200 bps using single time slot and dual time slot respectively for voice communications | 3600 bps |
| Vocoder | AMBE+2 (Advanced MultiBand Excitation) | AMBE+2 and its enhanced version AMBE+2e |
| Modulation | 4-level Frequency Shift Keying (4FSK) | 4-level Frequency Shift Keying (4FSK) |
| Encryption | 15 bit (basic), 56 bit (DES), 256 bit (AES) | 40 bit (ARC4), 56 bit (DES), 256 bit (AES) |
| Unit/Group ID | Unit ID (UID); Group ID (GID); Signaling Value Range 1 to 65519; 1 to 65519; RAN = None, 1 to 63 | 1 to 16776415 ; 1 to 16776415 ; color code = 0 to 15 |
| Standard References | Icom Incorporated, Kenwood Corporation | ETSI TS 102 361, DMR Association |
Conclusion
Both NXDN and DMR are versatile technologies suitable for a wide range of industries and applications. Their digital capabilities, clear voice quality, data features, and security make them ideal choices for professional and commercial users seeking reliable and efficient communication solutions in sectors like public safety, utilities, transportation, construction, manufacturing, hospitality, healthcare, oil and gas, and security services.
