RFAvalanche Photodiode vs. PIN Diode: A Detailed Comparison
Advertisement
The photodiode is a semiconductor device that operates based on the photovoltaic effect. Essentially, when light strikes the semiconductor material, it generates a small electrical current. When a photodiode is reverse-biased using a DC power source, it operates in photoconductive mode, which results in a higher current output.
PIN Photodiode
A PIN photodiode, much like a regular PIN diode, features an intrinsic (undoped) layer sandwiched between the p-type and n-type doped layers. This design provides more sensitive and faster responses compared to standard PN photodiodes.
Figure 1: P-I-N diode structure, illustrating the intrinsic layer between the P and N doped layers.
Avalanche Photodiode
When light falls on the undoped region of an avalanche photodiode, it initiates the creation of electron-hole pairs. As electrons move towards the avalanche region, the cumulative electric field intensifies, accelerating them to a point where collisions with the crystal lattice create even more electron-hole pairs. This “avalanche” effect makes it significantly more sensitive than a PIN photodiode.
Figure 2: Avalanche Photodiode structure.
However, this enhanced sensitivity also makes avalanche photodiodes more susceptible to electrical noise, which is considerably affected by temperature.
Key Differences: Avalanche Photodiode vs. PIN Photodiode
The following table summarizes the key differences between avalanche and PIN photodiodes:
| Features | Avalanche Photodiode | PIN Photodiode |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | As shown in figure-2 (P+, I, P, N+) | As shown in figure-1 (P, I, N) |
| Response time | Very high | Very low |
| Internal gain | 200 dB , Internally amplified gain | Insignificant |
| Sensitivity | High | Low |
| Electric noise | High | Low |
| Reverse bias voltage | Very high | Very low |
| Temperature stability | High | Low |
| Amplifier requirement | Not necessary | Mandatory |
| Speed | Generally slower | Generally faster |
| Dark current | Higher | Lower |
| Quantum efficiency | Typically higher | Typically lower |
Conclusion
The decision of whether to use an Avalanche Photodiode or a PIN photodiode hinges on the specific application’s requirements. The optimal choice involves balancing factors like sensitivity, speed, noise levels, and dark current to achieve the desired performance.
