I2S Bus: Advantages and Disadvantages

This page explores the advantages and disadvantages of the I2S bus, along with details on the I2S protocol and how it operates.

Introduction:

The I2S (Inter-IC Sound) interface was initially developed for use in CD player designs. Today, it’s widely used in various applications where digital audio data needs to be transferred between integrated circuits (ICs). You’ll find the I2S interface in most audio Analog-to-Digital Converters (ADCs), Digital-to-Analog Converters (DACs), Digital Signal Processors (DSPs), sample rate converters, and microcontrollers.

What is the I2S Bus?

I2S stands for Inter-IC Sound, and it’s a standard used to connect digital audio devices. The I2S bus is a three-line serial bus consisting of:

• Serial Data (SD)
• Word Select Line (WS)
• Clock Line (SCK)

Serial data is transmitted using 2’s complement format, with the Most Significant Bit (MSB) sent first.

Figure 1: Various configurations of the I2S bus used for digital audio data flow between various ICs.

An IC with an I2S port can be configured in either master mode or slave mode.

Figure 2: I2S bus interface timing diagram.

The Word Select line indicates the channel being transmitted. WS can change on either the trailing or leading edge of the serial clock:

• WS = 0: Channel 1 (Left)
• WS = 1: Channel 2 (Right)

Benefits (Advantages) of the I2S Bus

The I2S bus offers several benefits:

• Simple Receiver Designs: It uses separate clock and serial data lines, resulting in simpler receiver designs compared to asynchronous systems.
• No Data Synchronization Issues: With a single master device, there are no issues with data synchronization.
• Simplified Microphone Integration: I2S output-based microphones don’t require an analog front end. This is beneficial in wireless microphones with digital transmitters, allowing for a completely digital connection between the transducer and the transmitter.
• Low Jitter: The separate data and clock lines contribute to very low jitter.
• Fully Digital Audio Signal Chain: It delivers a fully digital audio signal chain, eliminating the need for ADCs/DACs and pre-amplifiers that are commonly found in traditional audio setups.

Figure 3: Traditional audio chain vs. all-digital audio chain.

Drawbacks (Disadvantages) of the I2S Bus

Despite its advantages, the I2S bus also has some limitations:

• Not Suitable for Cables: It’s not designed for data transfer over cables.
• Synchronization Problems: Synchronization issues between SCK, WS, and data signal lines can arise, especially at high sampling frequencies and bit rates. This is due to differences in propagation delays between the clock and data lines.
• No Error Detection: The lack of an error detection mechanism can lead to errors in data decoding.
• Lack of Standardization: There is no standard interconnecting cable and connectors defined for the I2S bus, leading to different manufacturers using different connectors.
• Limited to Inter-IC Communication: Primarily used for inter-IC communication on the same PCB.
• Bit Clock Rate Compatibility: Some ICs support a maximum of 32 or 48-bit clocks per stereo audio frame. System designers need to ensure compatibility when interfacing two ICs with different bit clock rates.

Further Reading:

Also, refer to the advantages and disadvantages of UART, SPI, and I2C, and the difference between I2C and I2S for more information.

Useful Interface Types:

• UART vs SPI vs I2C
• RS485 interface
• RS422 interface
• CAN interface
• SPI interface
• interface types and converters
• DigRF interface
• what is microcontroller
• microcontroller vs microprocessor
• microcontroller programming

What is the Difference Between:

• difference between OFDM and OFDMA
• Difference between SC-FDMA and OFDM
• Difference between SISO and MIMO
• Difference between TDD and FDD
• FDMA vs TDMA vs CDMA
• FDM vs TDM
• CDMA vs GSM