RFActive vs. Passive Remote Sensing: Key Differences
Advertisement
Active and passive remote sensing are two approaches to acquiring information about the Earth’s surface and atmosphere from a distance, and they differ in the way they capture and measure data.
What is Active Remote Sensing?
In active remote sensing, the sensor emits its own radiation (usually in the form of pulses of energy, such as radar or laser beams) towards the target, and the sensor measures the reflected or backscattered energy. The system actively interacts with the environment.
The active system provides its own energy source, which is directed towards the target. Examples include radar systems and LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging).
The timing of data acquisition is controlled by the sensor, as it actively sends out pulses of energy and measures the return time. This allows for precise control over when and where data is collected.
Applications: Common applications include terrain mapping, surface elevation measurement, and vegetation structure analysis. Radar systems are often used in active remote sensing applications.
Examples: Radar systems (e.g., Synthetic Aperture Radar or SAR), LiDAR, and sonar are examples of active remote sensing technologies.
What is Passive Remote Sensing?
In passive remote sensing, the sensor detects and records the natural radiation emitted or reflected by the Earth’s surface without emitting any energy of its own. It relies on ambient sources of radiation, such as sunlight or thermal radiation.
Passive systems rely on external sources of energy, such as the sun, to illuminate the target. Examples include optical sensors and thermal infrared sensors.
Passive sensors capture data whenever the natural radiation is available. They are dependent on external factors, such as sunlight or thermal emissions, and do not provide control over the timing of data acquisition.
Applications: Common applications include optical imagery for land cover classification, vegetation health assessment, and thermal infrared imagery for temperature mapping.
Examples: Optical sensors (e.g., cameras, multispectral sensors), thermal infrared sensors, and radiometers are examples of passive remote sensing technologies.
Difference between active and passive remote sensing
Here are the key differences between active and passive remote sensing systems.
| Parameters | Active Remote Sensing | Passive Remote Sensing |
|---|---|---|
| Energy source | Sensor provides its own energy e.g. radar, LiDAR etc. | Relies on external sources of energy e.g. sunlight |
| Interaction | Emits energy towards the target and measures the reflected or backscattered energy | Detects and records natural radiation emitted or reflected by surface of the Earth without emitting its own energy. |
| Timing of data acquisition | Controlled by the sensor | Dependent on external factors e.g. sunlight availability |
| Precision and control | Provides precise control over when and where data is collected. | Less control over the timing of data acquisition |
| Examples | Radar systems (e.g., Synthetic Aperture Radar or SAR), LiDAR, sonar | Optical sensors (e.g., cameras, multispectral sensors), thermal infrared sensors, radiometers |
| Applications or use cases | Terrain mapping, surface elevation measurement, vegetation structure analysis | Land cover classification, vegetation health assessment, temperature mapping |
| Advantages | Can penetrate clouds and operate in adverse weather conditions, can achieve high spatial resolution | Less energy consumption, environment friendly, simple system, very cost effective |
| Disadvantages | Consumes more energy, complex system, more expensive | Limited performance in cloudy or obscured conditions, Lower spatial resolution |
Conclusion
In summary, the primary distinction between active and passive remote sensing lies in whether the sensor actively emits energy or relies on ambient energy sources. Both approaches have their strengths and weaknesses, and the choice between them depends on the specific goals and requirements of the remote sensing application.
