Wired vs. Wireless Communication Networks: A Comprehensive Comparison
Advertisement
Wired and wireless networks represent two fundamental approaches to connecting devices for data communication. Wired networks rely on physical cables, while wireless networks utilize radio waves for communication.
Let’s compare wired and wireless networks based on their respective advantages and disadvantages.
Wired Communication Network
As the term suggests, a “wired” network refers to any physical medium employing cables. These cables can be copper wire, twisted pair, or fiber optic. Wired networks are designed to carry various forms of electrical signals from one end to the other, enabling a single internet connection to be shared among multiple devices.
Ethernet Network
Here are 10 examples of wired networks:
- Ethernet LAN (Local Area Network): This network comprises Ethernet cards housed in PCs or laptops, interconnected using Ethernet cables. Data flows between these cards. For small wired networks, a router connects a limited number of desktop or laptop computers. To expand network coverage, multiple Ethernet switches and routers are employed.
- Fiber Optic Network: This wired network type uses fiber optic cables, which transmit light signals to carry data over long distances with high speed and reliability. They are commonly used for internet backbones and high-speed data connections.
- Coaxial Cable Network: Coaxial cables are used for cable television (CATV) networks and some broadband internet connections.
- Telephone Line Network: Traditional telephone lines made of twisted pair cables can be used for data transmission. They are used for DSL (Digital Subscriber Line) internet connections.
- Powerline Communication (PLC): This technology uses electrical wiring to carry data signals, allowing devices to communicate through power outlets.
- USB (Universal Serial Bus): USB cables are commonly used to connect various peripherals like printers, external hard drives, keyboards, and mice to computers.
- HDMI (High Definition Multimedia Interface): HDMI cables transmit high-definition audio and video signals between devices such as computers, TVs, and gaming consoles.
- Thunderbolt Interface: These cables connect high-speed peripherals and monitors to computers, often found on Macintosh devices.
- Serial Cable: Serial cables are used for connecting older devices like serial printers, modems, and some industrial equipment.
- RS232: These interface cables are a type of serial cable used for asynchronous communication between computers and peripheral devices.
Wireless Network
“Wireless” refers to a medium that relies on electromagnetic waves (EM Waves) or infrared waves. All wireless devices require antennas for transmitting and receiving EM waves to and from the air. Common wireless devices include cellular mobiles, wireless sensors, TV remotes, satellite disc receivers, and laptops with Wi-Fi cards.
Wireless networks do not use physical wires for data or voice communication. Instead, they use EM waves at various frequencies for transmission and reception.
Cellular Network
Here are 10 examples of wireless networks:
- 4G LTE and 5G Cellular Networks: These mobile networks provide wireless internet access to smartphones, tablets, and other mobile devices. 5G NR (New Radio) networks offer faster speeds and lower latency compared to 4G LTE. Other cellular networks include 2G GSM, CDMA, and Mobile WiMAX.
- Wi-Fi Network: A router or Access Point (AP) is required to establish a Wireless LAN network, which follows IEEE 802.11 specifications. It allows various devices such as smartphones, laptops, and smart home devices to connect to the internet via a Wi-Fi AP or router.
- Bluetooth (IEEE 802.15.1): This short-range wireless technology allows Bluetooth-compliant devices to connect with each other or to a computer. Common devices include headphones, mice, keyboards, and smartphones.
- Zigbee: Zigbee is a wireless communication protocol used in smart home devices and IoT (Internet of Things) applications for home automation and wireless sensor networks (WSNs). It follows the IEEE 802.15.4 protocol.
- Z-Wave: Z-Wave is a wireless communication protocol primarily used for home automation and the Internet of Things (IoT).
- NFC (Near Field Communication): This short-range wireless technology is used for contactless payments, mobile ticketing, and data transfer between smartphones and other NFC-enabled devices.
- Satellite Internet: This technology uses satellite communication to provide high-speed internet access in remote or rural areas where traditional wired networks are not available. The satellite network uses various frequency bands for communications between satellites and ground stations.
- Infrared (IR) Network: Infrared is used for short-range communication between devices, for example, between a TV and its remote control. It was also used in older data transfer methods such as IrDA.
- RFID (Radio Frequency Identification): RFID is used for tracking and identifying objects or people through radio waves, commonly used in inventory management and access control systems.
- Microwave Links: Microwave backhaul utilizes a network of point-to-point microwave antennas to link cellular towers and the core network. Microwave systems use various frequency bands such as 2.4 GHz, 18 GHz, and so on for communication.
Difference between Wired and Wireless Networks
Let’s compare wired and wireless networks and mention 10+ differences between the wired and wireless network types used for communication.
Specifications | Wired network | Wireless network |
---|---|---|
Speed of operation | Higher | Lower compared to wired networks, but advanced wireless technologies such as LTE, LTE-A and WLAN-11ad will make it possible to achieve speed par equivalent to wired network |
System Bandwidth | High | Low, as Frequency Spectrum is a very scarce resource |
Cost | Less, as cables are not expensive | More, as wireless subscriber stations, wireless routers, wireless access points and adapters are expensive |
Installation | Wired network installation is cumbersome and it requires more time | Wireless network installation is easy and it requires less time |
Mobility | Limited, as it operates in the area covered by connected systems with the wired network | Not limited, as it operates in the entire wireless network coverage |
Transmission medium | copper wires, optical fiber cables, ethernet | EM waves or radio waves or infrared |
Network coverage extension | requires hubs and switches for network coverage limit extension | More area is covered by wireless base stations which are connected to one another. |
Applications | LAN (Ethernet), MAN | WLAN, WPAN(Zigbee, Bluetooth), Infrared, Cellular(GSM, CDMA, LTE) |
Channel Interference and signal power loss | Interference is less as one wired network will not affect the other | Interference is higher due to obstacles between wireless transmitter and receiver e.g. weather conditions, reflection from walls, etc. |
QoS (Quality of Service) | Better | Poor due to the high value of jitter and delay in connection setup |
Reliability | High compared to wireless counterpart, as manufactured cables have higher performance due to the existence of wired technology since years. | Reasonably high, This is due to the failure of the router will affect the entire network. |
Conclusion
Wired networks offer high reliability, faster data transfer speeds, and enhanced security but are stationary and require careful installation and maintenance. In contrast, wireless networks offer greater mobility and easier setup but are susceptible to interference.
The choice between the two depends on specific requirements and constraints including speed, mobility, reliability and other factors. In many cases, a combination of both wired and wireless technologies is used to create a hybrid network that leverages the benefits of each.