RFTD-SCDMA vs WCDMA vs CDMA2000: 3G Standard Comparison
Advertisement
When evaluating 3G mobile communication technologies, TD-SCDMA, WCDMA, and CDMA2000 stand out as major standards. Each of these technologies has unique characteristics, from the way they handle spectrum to their regional deployment. This page provides an in-depth comparison of TD-SCDMA, WCDMA, and CDMA2000, exploring their key features, technical approaches, and the differences that set them apart. Whether you are interested in global standards like WCDMA or region-specific solutions like TD-SCDMA and CDMA2000, understanding these differences is crucial for grasping the evolution of mobile communication technologies.
TD-SCDMA (Time Division Synchronous Code Division Multiple Access) Overview
TD-SCDMA is a 3G mobile telecommunications standard developed by the China Academy of Telecommunications Technology (CATT) in collaboration with Datang and Siemens. It was primarily used in China and is considered one of the three major 3G standards by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU).
Key Features:
- Time Division Duplex (TDD): Uses time slots to separate uplink and downlink communications within the same frequency band.
- Synchronous: Both the base station and mobile device are synchronized in time, which helps in reducing interference and improving spectral efficiency.
- Channel Bandwidth: Typically uses a channel bandwidth of 1.6 MHz or 5 MHz.
- Unique Aspects: Incorporates smart antenna technology and a more flexible use of resources.
WCDMA (Wideband Code Division Multiple Access) Overview
WCDMA is one of the primary 3G mobile communication technologies used worldwide. It is part of the UMTS (Universal Mobile Telecommunications System) standard and was developed as an evolution from the GSM standard.
Key Features:
- FDD (Frequency Division Duplex): Uses separate frequency bands for uplink and downlink.
- Wideband: Utilizes a wider frequency bandwidth (typically 5 MHz) compared to narrowband technologies.
- Code Division: Employs unique codes to distinguish between multiple users, allowing multiple communications simultaneously on the same frequency.
- Global Use: Widely adopted in Europe, Asia, and other regions, making it one of the most popular 3G technologies.
CDMA 2000 (Code Division Multiple Access 2000) Overview
CDMA 2000 is a family of 3G mobile communication standards developed by Qualcomm. It is an evolution of the cdmaOne technology and is widely used in North America and parts of Asia.
Key Features:
- FDD: Similar to WCDMA, CDMA2000 uses separate frequency bands for uplink and downlink.
- Backward Compatibility: Compatible with cdmaOne, allowing for easier upgrades and coexistence of different generations.
- Various Versions: Includes CDMA2000 1xRTT (1x Radio Transmission Technology), EV-DO (Evolution-Data Optimized), and others, providing various data rates and capabilities.
- Channel Bandwidth: Typically uses a 1.25 MHz channel bandwidth, making it narrower compared to WCDMA.
Difference between TD-SCDMA, WCDMA, CDMA 2000
| Specifications | TD-SCDMA | WCDMA | CDMA 2000 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full Form | Time Division-Synchronous Code Division Multiple Access, Utilizes concept of TDMA,FDMA,CDMA and SDMA | Wideband Code Division Multiple Access | Also known as IMT-2000, as the specifications introduced in service in the years 2000-2002. Supports 1x EV-DO (Evolution Data Only) and 1x EV-DV (Evolution Data and Voice) |
| RF Carrier Frequency | It is utilized in China, uses frequencies between 1785-2220 MHz | For 2100 MHz Band: 1920-1980 Uplink, 2110-2170 downlink, For 1900 MHz band: 1850-1910 Uplink, 1930-1990 Downlink, | 806-960 MHz, 1710-2025 MHz, 2110-2200 MHz 2500-2690 MHz |
| Channel Bandwidth | Uplink and downlink share 1.6 MHz band(for 1.28 Mcps) with 7 timeslots per frame, 16 codes per timeslot. 5MHz band is also specified for 3.84Mcps TDD case. | 5 MHz | 1.25 MHz |
| Frame Structure | Super frame=720ms, radio frame=10 ms, sub frame=5ms | 10 ms | 20 ms |
| Duplex technique | TDD | FDD | FDD |
| Spectrum Allocation | Need unpaired spectrum for both Downlink(DL) and Uplink(UL) | Need paired spectrum one for UL and the other for DL | Need paired spectrum one for UL and the other for DL |
| Spectrum Efficiency | For asymmetric traffic,the slots are allocated according to uasage and hence single spectrum is efficiently used for both DL and UL(TDD case). | For asymmetric traffic, as the bands are allocated dedicately for DL and UL, the spectrum gets wasted when there is no data to be send/receive. | For asymmetric traffic, as the bands are allocated dedicately for DL and UL, the spectrum gets wasted when there is no data to be send/receive. |
| Chip rate per carrier | 1.28 Mchips/sec | 3.84 Mchips/sec | 1.2288 Mchips/sec |
| Modulation supported | QPSK,8PSK,16QAM | QPSK, 16QAM | QPSK,8PSK,16QAM |
| Spreading Factor | 1/2/4/8/16 | 4 to 256 | - |
| Development | China Academy of Telecommunications Technology (CATT), Datang, Seimens | Developed under UMTS standard by 3GPP | Qualcomm |
| Forum website link | www.tdscdma-forum.org/en/ | www.umts-forum.org/ | www.umts-forum.org/ |
Summary
In summary, TD-SCDMA, WCDMA, and CDMA2000 are all 3G mobile communication standards with distinct characteristics and regional deployments.
- TD-SCDMA, primarily used in China, employs Time Division Duplex (TDD) and synchronous transmission, offering efficient spectrum utilization and incorporating smart antenna technology.
- WCDMA, the most widely adopted 3G standard globally, uses Frequency Division Duplex (FDD) with a wider bandwidth, providing high data rates and global interoperability.
- CDMA2000, prevalent in North America and parts of Asia, also uses FDD but with a narrower bandwidth, offering backward compatibility with cdmaOne and various data service options.
Conclusion
In summary, TD-SCDMA, WCDMA, and CDMA 2000 represent distinct paths in the development of 3G mobile communication. While TD-SCDMA finds its primary application in China with its TDD system and smart spectrum management, WCDMA dominates the global market with its wider bandwidth and FDD technology. CDMA2000, widely used in North America and Asia, stands out for its backward compatibility and narrower bandwidth. The choice between these standards often depends on regional needs, existing infrastructure, and technical requirements, with WCDMA taking the lead globally due to its versatility and widespread adoption. Understanding the differences between these technologies helps in making informed decisions for network implementations and upgrades.
