RFSigFox vs. GSM/CDMA: Technology Comparison
Advertisement
This article explores the key differences between SigFox and GSM (2G)/CDMA (3G) technologies. Let’s dive into a side-by-side comparison of their specifications and applications.
SigFox vs. GSM/CDMA: Key Specifications
The following table highlights the core differences between SigFox and GSM/CDMA based on various technical parameters:
| Specifications | SigFox | GSM(2G)/CDMA(3G) |
|---|---|---|
| Operating Frequency | 433 MHz, 868 MHz (Europe), 915 MHz (USA) | 850 MHz, 900 MHz, 1800 MHz, 1900 MHz (GSM) Band-I to Band-VI (UMTS) |
| Bandwidth | 200 KHz | 200 KHz |
| Data Rate | 10 to 1000 bps | 35 kbps for GSM (GPRS) |
| Coverage Distance | 10 to 12 Km (City), 40 to 60 Km (Country) | 3 Km (City), 30 Km (Countryside) |
| Frame Size (Payload) | 12 bytes | 140 bytes (for SMS) |
| Latency | ms to seconds | seconds |
| Typical Usage | Less than 200 bytes/day (min.) | About 5 Kbytes/day (max.) 1 SMS/day (140 bytes/day) |
| Applications | Telemetry, alarm, sensing, control, tracking | Mobile health, alarm status reporting |
| Unique Applications | Low power sensor related applications, direct D2D communication | |
| Link Budget | Up to 170 dB | About 145 dB |
Delving Deeper into the Differences
As you can see, SigFox and GSM cater to fundamentally different use cases. SigFox is designed for low-bandwidth, long-range communication, perfectly suited for applications like:
- Telemetry: Remotely collecting data from sensors.
- Alarm Systems: Sending alerts in case of emergencies.
- Sensing: Monitoring environmental conditions or infrastructure.
- Control: Remotely operating devices.
- Tracking: Locating assets or objects.
GSM, on the other hand, provides higher bandwidth and is geared towards applications like:
- Mobile Health: Remote patient monitoring and data transmission.
- Alarm Status Reporting: Communicating alarm events.
- SMS Messaging: Sending and receiving short text messages.
The key takeaway is that SigFox prioritizes power efficiency and wide-area coverage, making it ideal for battery-powered devices deployed over large areas. GSM prioritizes data throughput and is well-suited for applications requiring real-time communication and higher data volumes.
