COAP vs MQTT: Protocol Comparison

protocol
iot
coap
mqtt
data communication

This article compares the Constrained Application Protocol (COAP) and Message Queue Telemetry Transport (MQTT) protocols, highlighting their key differences.

COAP Protocol

CoAP Architecture

  • Full Name: Constrained Application Protocol
  • Specified in RFC 7252; an open IETF standard.
  • A highly efficient RESTful protocol, easily proxied to/from HTTP.
  • Utilizes an embedded web transfer protocol (coap://).
  • Employs an asynchronous transaction model.
  • Binds with UDP, offering reliability and multicast support.
  • Uses familiar methods like GET, POST, PUT, and DELETE.
  • URI support is included.
  • Features a small, simple 4-byte header.
  • Supports binding to UDP, SMS, and TCP.
  • DTLS-based PSK, RPK, and certificate security.
  • Utilizes a subset of MIME types and HTTP response codes.
  • Includes a built-in discovery mechanism.

MQTT Protocol

Broker based MQTT protocol

Figure 1 depicts a simple broker-based MQTT protocol architecture. Key features include:

  • Operates over TCP.
  • Uses SSL/TLS for security.
  • Defines various message types like CONNECT, PUBLISH, SUBSCRIBE, DISCONNECT, etc.
  • Utilizes Username/Password within the ‘connect’ message.
  • Payload agnostic, meaning it encrypts the payload regardless of its content.
  • Typically uses port 1883.

COAP vs MQTT: Feature Comparison

The following table compares features of COAP and MQTT:

FeaturesCoAPMQTT
Full FormConstrained Application ProtocolMessage Queue Telemetry Transport
Model used for communicationRequest-Response, Publish-SubscribePublish-Subscribe
RESTfulYesNo
Transport layerPreferably UDP, TCP can also be used.Preferably TCP, UDP can also be used (MQTT-S).
Header Size4 Bytes2 Bytes
Number of message types used416
MessagingAsynchronous & SynchronousAsynchronous
Application Reliability2 Levels3 Levels
SecurityIPSEC or DTLSNot defined in the standard
IntermediariesYESYES (MQTT-S)
LLN Suitability (thousand nodes)ExcellentFair
Application success storiesUtility Field Area NetworksExtending enterprise messaging into IoT applications
MQTT Interview Questions and Answers

MQTT Interview Questions and Answers

Ace your MQTT interview with these frequently asked questions about the protocol, its architecture, and differences from HTTP, CoAP, and REST.

mqtt
internet of things
iot