BAW Filter: Advantages and Disadvantages

This page covers the advantages and disadvantages of Bulk Acoustic Wave (BAW) filters, along with a basic introduction to the technology. We’ll explore the benefits and drawbacks of BAW filters in comparison to other filter types.

What is a BAW Filter?

Introduction: BAW stands for Bulk Acoustic Wave technology. Unlike conventional filters, a BAW filter stores the signal in acoustic resonators. BAW filters typically operate in the frequency range of 1.5 GHz to 6 GHz.

BAW filter structure

BAW filters are generally designed using two main architectures:

• SMRs (Solidly Mounted Resonators)
• FBARs (Film Bulk Acoustic Resonators)

The diagram above illustrates the basic structure of a BAW filter. An electric field excites an acoustic wave, which then travels vertically through the piezoelectric substrate. The resonant frequency is determined by the thickness of this piezoelectric layer. To create the BAW filter or resonator, various metal films are deposited on top and bottom of the piezoelectric materials. These films can be aluminum for lower power levels or tungsten for higher power levels.

Benefits or Advantages of BAW Filters

Compared to SAW (Surface Acoustic Wave) filters operating at the same higher frequencies, BAW filters offer several advantages:

• Higher Component Density: BAW technology yields approximately four times more parts per wafer, leading to greater component density compared to SAW filters.
• Lower Loss: BAW filters generally exhibit lower signal loss.
• Higher Q: They offer a higher Q factor (Quality factor), indicating better selectivity and lower energy dissipation.
• Higher Power Handling Capacity: BAW filters can handle higher power levels without performance degradation.
• Greater Selectivity: They provide better selectivity, meaning they can more effectively isolate the desired frequency band.
• Less Temperature Variation: BAW filter devices are less susceptible to temperature-induced variations compared to SAW filters.

Drawbacks or Disadvantages of BAW Filters

Despite their advantages, BAW filters also have some drawbacks:

• Higher Manufacturing Cost: BAW filters are generally more expensive to manufacture than SAW filters.
• More Complex Fabrication: The manufacturing process requires significantly more steps; approximately ten times more processing steps than SAW filter fabrication, making it a more complex undertaking.
• Performance Degradation at Higher Frequencies: The performance of BAW filters tends to degrade at higher frequencies. As a result, other filter types are often preferred for designs exceeding 6 GHz, particularly in millimeter-wave bands.