Terminology » Other Wireless » AC vs. DC Transmission: Advantages and Disadvantages

AC vs. DC Transmission: Advantages and Disadvantages

power transmission ac transmission dc transmission electrical engineering power systems

This article compares AC (Alternating Current) and DC (Direct Current) transmission, highlighting their differences, advantages, and disadvantages.

Advantages of DC Transmission

  • Fewer Conductors: DC transmission requires only two conductors.
  • Reduced Inductance, Capacitance, and Phase Displacement Issues: DC transmission doesn’t suffer from the inductance, capacitance, and phase displacement problems that are common in AC transmission.
  • Lower Voltage Drop: The voltage drop in DC transmission is less than in AC transmission for the same load and sending-end voltage.
  • Full Conductor Utilization: The entire cross-section of the conductor is utilized in DC transmission because there’s no skin effect.
  • Reduced Stress on Insulating Materials: DC lines experience less stress compared to AC lines for the same voltage value on insulating materials.
  • Lower Corona Loss and Reduced Interference: DC lines have less corona loss and reduced interference in communication electronics.
  • Stable System: DC transmission systems are stable, unlike AC transmission systems which can be unstable.

Disadvantages of DC Transmission

  • Difficult High-Voltage Generation: Generating power at high DC voltages is difficult due to commutation problems. Furthermore, it cannot be easily utilized at the consumer load.
  • No Step-Up/Step-Down Transformation: Step-up or step-down transformation of DC voltages is not possible with equipment like transformers.

Advantages of AC Transmission

  • Easier High-Voltage Generation: Power can be generated at high voltages without the commutation problems faced by DC systems.
  • Convenient Voltage Transformation: AC voltages can be conveniently stepped up or stepped down using transformers.
  • Reduced Losses at High Voltage: High-voltage AC transmission reduces power losses.

Disadvantages of AC Transmission

  • Inductance and Capacitance Issues: Problems of inductances and capacitances exist in transmission lines.
  • Skin Effect: Due to the skin effect, more copper is needed for transmission.
  • Complex and Costly Construction: The construction of AC transmission lines is more complex and costly.
  • Increased Effective Resistance: The effective resistance of AC transmission lines is increased due to the skin effect.