Compare OFDM vs OFDMA
This page on the OFDM vs OFDMA describes difference between OFDM and OFDMA modulation schemes. The tabular comparison between OFDM and OFDMA are also outlined.
In OFDM systems, only a single user can transmit on all of the sub-carriers at any given time. In order to support multiple users time and/or frequency division access techniques are used in OFDM. The major setback to this static multiple access scheme is the fact that the different users see the wireless channel differently is not being utilized. OFDMA, on the other hand, allows multiple users to transmit simultaneously on the different sub-carriers per OFDM symbol.
OFDM is employed in Fixed WiMAX system deployed around the world for broadband internet service. Figure 1 depicts OFDM frame structure employed in fixed WiMAX system.
Here Downlink sub frame is transmitted by Base station to subscriber stations and Uplink sub frame is transmitted by multiple subscriber stations to the Base Station. Both the frame is composed of more than one OFDM symbols and each symbol is made up of subcarriers, which fall in data and pilot subcarriers, where data subcarriers carry the user data. There are 192 data sub carriers in Fixed WiMAX System. The point here is Subscriber station has been assigned one or more symbols by BS and all the data carriers(i.e. 192) of the symbols are occupied by one SS. It is depicted in the figure-1 that entire 256 carriers are allocated to the one user statically in TDD frame.
Figure-1 : OFDM modulation frame structure as per 16d standard
To undertand difference between OFDM and OFDMA, one should understand basic difference between OFDM and FDM multiplexing techniques in addition to OFDM physical layer and OFDMA physical layer as per fixed wimax and mobile wimax standards.
In the case of OFDMA, which is employed in Mobile WiMAX system deployed around the world and also employed in LTE system being deployed, total subcarriers are permuted and assigned to sub channel. Hence many SSs can occupy the same sub channel but use different subcarriers to transmit the information.
Figure 2 describes OFDMA frame used in Mobile WiMAX System. It clearly mentions that one symbol is composed of
more than one sub channel and each sub channel is composed of distributed subcarriers.
The point here is each symbol is used by more number of SSs to transmit and receive the
information which is depicted by Burst 1 and Burst 2 in the figure.
As mentioned in OFDMA subcarriers are divided among users at the same time instant.
Figure mentions 2048 FFT case here. Total 2048 subcarriers of FFT is divided among 60 subchannels.
Each subchannels will have their own pilot and data subcarriers.
Figure-2 : OFDMA modulation frame structure as per 16e standard
The Frame structures mentioned here only for demonstrating the concept and it differs in the actual wimax system.
Both OFDM and OFDMA is used to achieve high data rate transmission over the air. With OFDMA system can support more subscribers with sub channelization concept compare to OFDM.
Both OFDM and OFDMA is implemented using IFFT and FFT operation at transmitter and receiver respectively. For OFDM entire input of IFFT is occupied fully by either subscriber staion or Base Station. For OFDMA part of input values (consecutively) is occupied by Subscriber station and at rest of the input positions zeros or nulls are inserted. Same is done with other subscribers and so on.
Further OFDM vs OFDMA can be explored by studying comparison between WiMAX and LTE standards. Refer wimax vs lte page in terminology section.
Difference between OFDM and OFDMA
Following table summarize important comparison between OFDM and OFDMA modulation types.
|Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing
|Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access
|Divides a high-speed data stream into multiple parallel substreams, each modulated onto different orthogonal subcarriers.
|Builds upon OFDM by allowing multiple users to access and share the same spectrum simultaneously by assigning subsets of subcarriers to different users.
|Single User (SU)
|Multiple Users (MU)
|Assigned to a single user
|Assigned dynamically to multiple users
|Less effective in managing interference when multiple users are involved.
|More effective in managing interference as users' subcarriers can be spatially separated and allocated dynamically.
|Performance in Congestion
|More prone to congestion as resources are not dynamically allocated among users.
|More resilient to congestion as resources are dynamically assigned based on demand.
|Robustness against fading/interference
|Less robust to fading as well as interference.
|More robust to fading as well as interference compare to OFDM.
|Wired systems such as DSL, WiFi, Fixed wimax PHY, refer OFDM physical layer➤
|Mobile wimax PHY, 5G etc. refer OFDMA physical layer➤
Conclusion : In conclusion, while both OFDM and OFDMA are based on the principle of dividing the available spectrum into multiple orthogonal subcarriers, their key distinction lies in their approach to multiple access and resource allocation. OFDM primarily caters to single-user communication with fixed resource allocation, whereas OFDMA extends this concept to accommodate multiple users by dynamically assigning subsets of subcarriers based on user demand. This enables OFDMA to achieve higher spectral efficiency, scalability, and interference management, making it the preferred choice for modern multi-user wireless communication systems such as 5G and WiMAX.
OFDM and OFDMA RELATED LINKS
Refer following links which mentions OFCDM, OFDM and OFDMA Physical layers(PHY) as per IEEE 802.11a(WLAN), 802.16d(Fixed WiMAX) and IEEE 802.11ad.
It mentions difference between OFDM and other terms which include OFDM vs DMT, OFDM vs FBMC, SC-FDMA vs OFDMA, OFDM vs CDMA etc.
What is Difference between
Difference between SC-FDMA and OFDM
Difference between SISO and MIMO
Difference between TDD and FDD
FDMA vs TDMA vs CDMA
FDM vs TDM